So as I was reading the always great Go Teams Go NASCAR Forum, I came across a post of posters who were spewing venom about a recent article by David Poole of the Charlotte Observer. I headed over to check it out and sure enough, most of his “myths” are definitely his opinion and his opinion only. Let’s take a look at a few here and set the record straight from your ordinary average NASCAR fan.
1. “The top-35 rule is killing the sport’s smaller teams.”
I wouldn’t say this was a myth at all. I agree with this statement. I’m in the camp that thinks the 43 fastest cars in qualifying should make the field no matter if they are #1 in the points or #101. That would definitely shake up the Chase and keep drivers and teams on their toes. As it stands, cars that have to qualify to get in a race are so far behind on impound race days because they have to run a qualifying set up while cars who are guaranteed a spot can rest easy and qualify in their race trim. Level out the playing field and make everyone qualify every week. Maybe that will knock the wind out of some of the bigger teams and get those one car operations back in the game.
2. “The lack of personality among NASCAR drivers is killing the sport.”
I don’t know that I’ve ever heard this mentioned before, let alone it being the second biggest myth that needs disputing. I do think this statement is a myth, so it does belong on a list of myths, but perhaps not quite so high on that list. I think there is plenty of personality in the garage. Anyone who watches interviews or the SPEED channel can see that. Part of this myth may come from the fact that NASCAR frowns on any sort of temper flairs or opinionated commentary, which makes it hard for some of the guys to be themselves fully on camera. However, you can’t say that Tony Stewart or Kevin Harvick show no personality, just to name a couple. They seem to always be able to speak their minds with little to no problem.
3. “The Chase for the Cup is killing the sport.”
I’m on the fence about this one. I do think that the Chase is favoring the bigger teams and that’s hurting things. However, it all comes down to strategy and there are just a few teams who have that head game all figured out. I would like to see some other drivers have a chance once in awhile (I’m looking at you, Hendrick Motorsports), but teams who work together deserve some sort of credit. Afterall, racing is a pretty individual sport and it’s rare to see really solid teamwork. I do agree that the Chase format needs some more tweaking, but maybe that will come with time.
4. “Open-wheel racers are killing stock-car racing by taking away rides.”
I guess I’m not sure about this one, either. I’m not a huge fan of open wheel racing, so it does seem sort of like favoritism when these guys get brought over with little to no experience in stock cars and get put into a well established team and ride. I don’t want to take anything at all away from these very talented drivers, but I do wish teams would make them spend a season in the Craftsman Truck series or the Nationwide Series before just hopping straight into a Cup car. I’m sure Joe Nemechek and Sterling Marlin were saying the same thing when their rides were swiped away and all the bigger teams turned to open wheel racers to sub or drive for them instead of the veteran stock car racers.
5. “NASCAR’s new fans are killing the sport for its longtime fans.”
Now this is one statement I agree is a myth. It’s probably because I consider myself a new fan rather than a longtime fan. Sure, I remember every now and then watching a race with my brother when I was little and cheering for Richard Petty, but I didn’t really start watching and loving NASCAR until I married my husband 5 years ago. I am a new fan, but I think I have a somewhat longtime fan mentality. I’m not watching because it’s the passing fad or I just want to see crashes. I love knowing about the cars and the strategies and following my favorite drivers and rooting against those I don’t like. I appreciate that it’s a sport and it takes an entire team to win. I do, however, really enjoy the interviews and back stories of the drivers and crews and I watch SPEED Channel all the time. So I don’t think we’re killing the sport…are we?
6. “Racing just isn’t like it was in the “good old days” and that is killing the sport.”
Racing isn’t like it was in the “good old days”. It’s a multi-million dollar corporation now. The “stock cars” aren’t so much stock anymore. However, it’s safer and I think that’s a good thing. I think some of the new rules and regulations aren’t helping grow the sport, but is it really killing it? It’s still fun to watch and cheer for my favorite driver, so I don’t know if it truly is dying.
Let me know what you think about these myths. Is NASCAR dying? Leave some comments. Just a note: your comment may not appear right away because we’re having issues with our spam filter, but it will be up as soon as I fish it out and approve it, so no worries! Comment away!